What Should You Compare Before Switching Medicare Plans? A Practical Checklist

Pennsylvania

 Residents:

This guide answers the most common questions people as when choosing a Medicare Advantage plan. Below, you'll find every topic covered, with links to simple, plain-English, answers for each.

Last Updated:
May 9, 2026
Older man with shingles but luckily insured with medicare with gray hair and beard sitting on the beach, shielding his eyes and gazing at the ocean waves.

Switching Medicare plans can be a big decision, and it’s important to make sure you’re making the right choice for your health needs and budget. This checklist will help you compare your current plan with any new options you might consider.

Health Coverage: What Does Each Plan Cover?

When comparing Medicare plans, start by looking at what each plan covers in terms of medical services and treatments. Here are some key areas to review:

Doctors and Specialists: Check which doctors and specialists are included in the plan’s network. If you have a favorite doctor or specialist, make sure they’re covered under the new plan.

Prescription Drugs: Medicare Part D plans cover prescription drugs, but the coverage can vary widely from one plan to another. Look at the list of covered medications and their costs.

Special Needs: If you have specific health conditions like diabetes or heart disease, ensure that the new plan covers your treatments and specialists.

It’s also a good idea to check if there are any services or treatments not covered by the new plan but covered by your current one. For example, some plans may not cover certain types of therapy or dental work.

Cost: What Will You Pay?

Cost is often the deciding factor when choosing between Medicare plans. Here’s what you should consider:

Monthly Premiums: This is the amount you pay every month to keep the plan active. Compare this with your current premiums.

Deductibles: This is how much you need to spend out-of-pocket before your insurance starts covering costs. Some plans have high deductibles, which means you might pay more upfront for services.

Copayments and Coinsurance: These are the amounts you pay each time you get a service or medication. Copays are fixed amounts, while coinsurance is a percentage of the total cost.

Also, don’t forget to factor in any extra costs like deductibles for Part A hospital stays or gaps in your drug coverage during the donut hole period.

Network: Where Can You Get Care?

The network of healthcare providers can vary greatly between Medicare plans. Here’s how you can compare them:

In-Network vs. Out-of-Network: In-network providers are those who have a contract with your plan to give discounts on their services, while out-of-network providers do not. Using an in-network provider is almost always cheaper.

Location: Make sure the new plan has hospitals and doctors near you or wherever you might travel frequently.

For example, if you travel often, you may want a plan that has a broad network of providers across different states.

Customer Service: How Easy Is It to Get Help?

Good customer service can make all the difference when you have questions about your coverage. Here are some ways to compare:

Contact Options: Look at how many ways you can contact the plan’s customer service, such as phone, email, or live chat.

Response Time: How quickly does the customer service team respond? This can be a deciding factor if you need immediate help with your coverage.

Member Reviews: Check online reviews from current members to get an idea of how satisfied they are with the plan’s support.

Before making any changes, it’s also helpful to call both plans and ask them specific questions about their services. This will give you firsthand experience with how each plan handles inquiries.

Conclusion

Switching Medicare plans is a significant step that requires careful consideration. By comparing health coverage, costs, network options, and customer service, you can make an informed decision that best fits your needs.

Not affiliated with or endorsed by the federal Medicare program or any government agency.

Get personalized help choosing a Medicare plan

Peter Abilla is a licensed Medicare agent. No pressure, no cost — just clarity on your options.

Independent agent. Not affiliated with any carrier.
Elderly woman with white hair in a bun, sitting on a beige chair, reading a book indoors.

Questions Covered in This Guide

How This Applies to 

Pennsylvania

 Residents

Medicare Part B covers most outpatient cardiology services including EKGs, echocardiograms, and specialist consultations. Medicare Advantage plans cover the same services but with different copay structures.

Older man with gray hair explains medicare insurance to young girl standing on the beach, both pointing towards something in the distance.Elderly couple rejoice in their medical coverage wearing sunglasses dancing outdoors on a sunny day with a coastal landscape in the background.Smiling mature man forgets his medicare insurance id and woman high-fiving while sitting on a couch in a bright living room.